After a Rough Start, Hawaiian Did Things Right… Mostly (Trip Report)


After a hurried run through the Big Island thanks to losing a day from our previous fiasco getting to Hawaiʻi, I was hopeful the rest of the trip would go smoothly. It did not start off that way when I went to check in for our flight from Hilo to Kahului for the second part of the trip.

After pulling up the app, I was greeted by a message saying our reservations had been canceled. Crap.

My first thought was that the agent screwed up yet again when we didn’t take the first flights after that 14-hour delay, so everything had been auto-canceled. But before I jumped to conclusions, I picked up the phone. I decided not to call Hawaiian at all and instead called Alaska to get some help this time.

A Boise-based agent answered and told me that everything looked fine on his end. That was a relief, but… what was going on with the app? After he investigated, he said it was because the original Hawaiian agent had done something she was not supposed to do. (SHOCK!) She refunded our original coupons before the trip was finished, and somehow the app interpreted this as our itinerary having been canceled.

Let’s forget about how stupid this is for the app to work this way. What really bugged me was when he said that this meant we’d have to see an agent at the airport to check in. No kiosks. An agent. Ugh. But then, I decided I didn’t trust anything, so I went on the website. Sure enough it let me check in. The app? It absolutely wouldn’t even admit these reservations existed, but the website worked. Alaska’s technology really is… something.

The next morning we were off early to get to the airport, and that’s when I discovered that traffic in Hilo can get very, very bad. Google Maps didn’t seem to know what to make of it, and our arrival time kept climbing and climbing and climbing. We had to skip the gas station visit and swallow the sky-high prices from the rental car agency. We weren’t worried about missing our flight, but we were worried that our eventual ETA of 7:39am was going to give us six minutes to get those checked bags tagged.

Fortunately, the rental car drop in Hilo is right across from the terminal. So, I pulled in, and the family jumped out to run across and get the bags tagged. I joined them shortly after, and only then could we all take a deep breath.

We walked through the empty security line which offered only TSA Precheck-light where you get the piece of paper giving you permission to go through the metal detector. On the other side, we found one of my favorite, relaxing airport terminals. It just feels so welcoming with those chairs and couches.

To get to the gates, you have to head upstairs where it is decidedly less spacious.

We found a couple spots to sit, and they called for boarding. I’m not sure why, but I was in B and everyone else in my family was in C. You’d think people in the same reservation would at least be put together, but I guess that’s not how it works. The agents said we should just board in B, so we did… until we got to the end of the jet bridge. That’s when my daughter panicked, saying she had forgotten her suitcase in the waiting area.

A quick swim upstream and one of the agents offered to go get it for her. He brought it over (along with her sweatshirt, oy vey), and then we could go back down to the airplane.

Hawaiian 1019
August 5, 2026

From Hilo
➤ Scheduled Departure: 830a
➤ Actual Departure: 832a
➤ From Gate: 6
➤ Wheels Up: 838a
➤ From Runway: 26

To Kahului
➤ Wheels Down: 902a
➤ On Runway: 2
➤ Scheduled Arrival: 910a
➤ Actual Arrival: 911a
➤ At Gate: 21

Aircraft
➤ Type: Boeing 717-22A
➤ Delivered: June 28, 2001
➤ Registered: N480HA, msn 55125
➤ Livery: Maile Lei colors, “Pueo”

Flight
➤ Cabin: Coach in Seat 7A
➤ Load: ~66% Full
➤ Flight Time: 24m

They seem to be trying to set a record for the number of stickers on the side of these airplanes.

Onboard, the flight attendants were cheerful even though we had been a bit late to start boarding. The relatively light load made it easy to finish up on time, and then we were off.

They taxi these airplanes like they work for Southwest. We headed over to the end of runway 26 for a westbound departure, which seems like it’s probably rare since it goes against the tradewinds. We made a right turn to give enough room between us and the clouds gathering around Maunakea.

Soon after, the flight attendants sprang into action. Naturally, I had a cup of POG juice which is just the right amount of that sweet beverage. Others had coffee.

We hit a cruising altitude of 12,000 feet which was remarkable since that meant we stayed a couple thousand feet lower than when we were at Maunakea’s summit the night before.

After a short crossing of the Alenuihaha Channel, we were descending into Maui. Sitting on the left side, we had a stunning view of Kahoʻolawe, the island formerly used for military ordnance testing which remains off limits. Then it was a straight shot into Kahului.

Despite the check-in hiccups, everything else went well. It would be one week of finally being able to relax before heading back home.

The day before it was time to go home, I went online to check in since the app still wasn’t going to work. I got us checked in, put the boarding passes in my Google Wallet, and then hoped for a 14-hour delay like on the way out. I’m only half-kidding, since a really lengthy delay would give me one more night before heading home. It did not materialize.

We dropped off the rental car, and then took the silly train to the terminal instead of what the airport itself says is a 3 minute walk. I find just about everything about this little train to be annoying. We waited for 3 minutes just for it to take us.

Once we crossed the curbs, we put our checked bags into the machines to make sure we weren’t sneaking anything agricultural off the island. Then we went to print out our bag tags and drop the bags off. Lines were short, so we were at security quickly.

The brand new, giant checkpoint at the south end of the terminal is well underway (and will further make the silly rental car train useless), so eventually security will be better.

But for now, it was just a long line that moved fast through the checkpoint.

Up top, we headed toward the gate. Except for a new outdoor area to sit, the entire southern end of the concourse has now been enclosed, and there is air conditioning throughout, which is very welcome. In addition, there is one brand new gate 7.

That looks nothing like the other gates.

They started to board on time, but there was some difficulty since Southwest’s boarding announcements could be heard in our gate area. There were a lot of people walking up to say, “they called groups 1 and 2, but I’m in group C, so when do I board?” The agents made more than one announcement telling everyone this was a different airline. Eventually, we all got onboard.

Hawaiian 972
August 12, 2026

From Kahului
➤ Scheduled Departure: 1211p
➤ Actual Departure: 1208p
➤ From Gate: 13
➤ Wheels Up: 1217p
➤ From Runway: 2

To Long Beach
➤ Wheels Down: 814p
➤ On Runway: 30
➤ Scheduled Arrival: 816p
➤ Actual Arrival: 818p
➤ At Gate: 11

Aircraft
➤ Type: Airbus A321-271N
➤ Delivered: May 24, 2019
➤ Registered: N220HA, msn 8872
➤ Livery: Maile Lei colors, “Milo”

Flight
➤ Cabin: Coach in Seat 18B
➤ Load: ~99% Full
➤ Flight Time: 4h57m

We found our preferred (but not Premium) seats and settled in. I still like the cloth seating. It feels much more comfortable to me.

Boarding finished up a few minutes early, and that’s when the cold war with my seatmate began. My son was in the window, so I got the middle. Next to me was an older woman who kept putting her arm on my armrest. Normally, I don’t really care that much. There was room for both of us. But the armrest was loose, and she moved a lot. So every time she would move, it would shake me. That wasn’t pleasant. (I reported the loose armrest, so they could write it up.)

This is the first time I’ve heard a pilot announce on pushback, “flight attendants, this is going to be a quick taxi so take your seats.” And indeed, it was. We climbed around some clouds and then it was mostly smooth. Despite that, the pilots kept the seatbelt sign on for more than an hour, probably to keep the aisles clear for service.

The flight attendants came through with a drink service and a bag of Maui chips for all. Then, after a few more minutes, they came through with the meals. I loved my corned beef hash from Chef Sheldon last month, but this was the moment of truth

I had ordered the vaunted Mochiko chicken. When I was on Maui, we went to Tiffany’s which is a restaurant Chef Sheldon took over, and I had an incredible crispy chicken.

But doing something like that at altitude? That’s impossible.

To solve the issue of the chicken not being crunchy when reheated, Chef Sheldon came up with the idea of putting a little spice/crunch packet in the meal which you pour on the chicken which in turn sits on a bed of noodles. There are no instructions, so be warned. (My wife put it on the mac salad.)

So how was it? It was good. It wasn’t an absolute rave like the corned beef hash, but maybe my expectations were too high. The whole family said they liked it though, and that never happens. So I’ll take that as a win.

The real test for me, however, was the mac salad. I love a Hawaiian mac so much, and this one… didn’t do it for me. It was a good consistency and all that, but the flavor just wasn’t there. It seemed really bland, which is a problem for all food at altitude. Bummer.

I had set up my phone in the device holder, so I could stream the end of the Diamondbacks game. (We lost the series to the Rockies? Come on….) It took awhile for the trash to be picked up, but once that happened, I broke out my computer.

About five minutes later, the guy in front of me reclined. This was very cramped. I had my water in the tray table cupholder, so my computer was skewed to the left. The screen was bent forward when the seat reclined, and my t-rex arms came out. Don’t forget the armrest that would shake when the woman next to me moved. It wasn’t great, but hey, that’s coach.

To make things even more annoying, the woman on the aisle asked us to close the window shade. We would do no such thing, but we did lower it a bit to get the direct sun off. She seemed satisfied.

The flight attendants came through with the chocolate-covered macadamia nut “sweet treat” about 50 minutes before arrival. Unfortunately, they didn’t bring through any more water. We only had one water service in the middle of the flight.

At the top of descent, the pilots came on and again said something else I’d never heard. They asked us to get off the airplane quickly when we landed, so they could get to their hotel since they had an early morning the next day. That seemed odd since we were landing just a couple minutes late. (And yes, the flight went on time the next day.)

We had a very nice descent in as the sun set quickly behind us, the lights of Long Beach growing closer by the minute.

It was a routine landing and quick taxi to the gate. But by the time we got off the airplane, we saw this.

I had initially thought something must have gone wrong, but they do scheduled maintenance in Long Beach, so maybe they were just eager to move fast. Or maybe something was wrong and they were quick on the draw.

Either way, we grabbed our bags and then it was a 10 minute Lyft home. Remind me why I fly out of LAX again?

Get Cranky in Your Inbox for Free

How often do you want to receive emails?
Brett Avatar

22 responses to “After a Rough Start, Hawaiian Did Things Right… Mostly (Trip Report)”

  1. Matt D Avatar
    Matt D

    Someone pointed it out to me on a FB post and now I can’t unsee it.

    Look at modern Pualani compared to when she was a young pretty Island girl. Now, she has the look and expression of a dominatrix.

    The person said that is right. She does.

    You’re welcome.

  2. emac Avatar
    emac

    Was expecting at least a couple paragraphs extolling Long Beach’s finest DC-9 progeny…

  3. MaxPower Avatar
    MaxPower

    “Despite that, the pilots kept the seatbelt sign on for more than an hour, probably to keep the aisles clear for service.”

    I really don’t understand why US airlines are such abusers of the seatbelt sign for what seems like anything but safety.

    If you’re on any European airline it always seems as though you’re taking your life in your own hands when the seatbelt sign is off whereas US Pilots use it to allow for “safety” to allow inflight service, prevent inflight service completely, or in some cases for no fathomable reason or because they forgot.
    People often reference the US litigious nature of the USA for a reason the sign is kept on for such unreasonable time periods but it seems like more than that, at times.

  4. GringoLoco Avatar
    GringoLoco

    Raised in SAN (and son of a Padres inaugural season ticket holder) then a long-term resident of Snotsdale (and D’backs inaugural season ticket holder), I am soooooo conflicted this season. The last weekend series could be a doozie

    1. Brett Avatar

      GringoLoco – No conflict over here, let’s go Dbacks! I do find myself wondering if I need to hop on the Pacific Surfliner to go see one of those last 3 games. If it keeps up as it has been, that series will be incredible.

      1. Patrick Avatar
        Patrick

        Isn’t that track underwater now?

        1. Brett Avatar

          Patrick – Only supposed to be through tomorrow… but it’s Amtrak, so… maybe I’ll drive.

  5. 1990 Avatar
    1990

    Great report! And, nice use of “(SHOCK!)” Bah! To write about those 717 is one thing; to actually hop on one (and, to get one of the coveted sets of ‘2’ among the ‘2-3’ configuration) is another. (More guava juice, please!)

    Speaking of Hawaiian (sorry, Alaska Airlines, *cough*), there’s that issue with N780HA (ex-Hawaiian 787-9) still stuck at FCO (lots of rumors on FlyerTalk, Reddit, etc., ‘braking issue’ then parts, crew, staffing issues? Yikes.) Seems that’s affecting AS operations more broadly. Running too thin!

    Speaking of LA area airports, recently back at LAX (on arrival, tried their new mini-D1 lounge at T2; still prefer the main one at T3), and the shuttle buses to rental car center (beautiful new building, alas, no people movers yet… *sigh*). Also, flew out of SNA (John Wayne… ‘where ya headed, pilgrim?’), which reminded me of Palm Beach airport for whatever reason (more so, terminal design, etc.) Interestingly, instead of going out over the Pacific, we took off to north/east on 2L (signature full-thrust, steep climb on DL’s 752; was like a rocket ship! VROOM!)

    1. GM Avatar
      GM

      They are back working on the people mover track again. This time on the incline west of the economy parking station. Last time they were down for a month. I don’t think the DBO bunch can blame LAWA for this. seems to be a pretty clear case of construction defects pushing it back now.

  6. JohnG Avatar
    JohnG

    Brett’s experience brings a question.

    Who owns the armrest?

    I’ve always kind of worked under the assumption that the person in the middle generally gets the armrest since they have room on the other side.

    Thoughts?

    1. PleaseStopthemisinformation Avatar
      PleaseStopthemisinformation

      There are a series of bloggers suggesting that there is an “answer” to this. There is not. Each person bought a seat. The space is often too small. People should be courteous and figure it out, but the notion that bloggers get to push a narrative that the middle seat person gets “both” armrests is hogwash. Worse, it’s terrible. They do not run or own the airlines, and there is precisely nothing in the Contract of Carriage that addresses who gets the armrests.

      It’s usually good manners to share, no doubt. But, there is definitely not a firm answer to this question.

    2. Brett Avatar

      JohnG – While there is no official rule, it’s pretty clear that the middle seat should get the armrest. The person in the window can lean on the window and use that armrest exclusively. The person on the aisle can cheat toward the aisle and use that armrest exclusively. The person in the middle has nowhere to go, so it’s only fair. Your assumption is the humane way to look at it.

      1. stogieguy7 Avatar
        stogieguy7

        I agree 100% with this. It’s one small thread in the fabric that holds society together.

      2. JT8D Avatar
        JT8D

        Agree. I need to say that again or I’m not allowed to post. Agree.

    3. Patrick Avatar
      Patrick

      If everybody made planes like Embraer there would be no such thing as a middle seat. What a wonderful world that would be. The E175 has become my favorite plane.

  7. JD Avatar
    JD

    Brett, I certainly see why you named your blog the crankyflier. Your criticism of everything on board wreaks of an infrequent traveler whose expectations are far too high. Perhaps my expectations on reading this post were too high. For a seasoned traveler and industry veteran such as yourself, a more balanced report might be appropriate.

  8. SAN Greg Avatar
    SAN Greg

    Great trip report! I’m sorry the mac salad didn’t slap for you. Perhaps because of the altitude thing like you said.

  9. Yo Avatar
    Yo

    Brett, we just got back from a trip to La Paz, Mexico, partially inspired by your review. We loved La Paz, so quiet, and the people were great. But we went at the wrong time of the year, it was oppressively humid and hot, mid 90’s with 85% humidity. Still, we ate like pigs, and did a nice boat trip out to Espiritu Santu Island. We flew into SJD and that crowd was weird, I really don’t enjoy Cabo, its so garish, loud and full of DB’s, we had interesting seatmates, one never wore her seat belt and spent the flight taking social media influencer pictures and applying makeup for the entire flight, one guy had the balls to ask the FA for a bigger seat with more legroom, in coach, the FA said “There are seats up front with more legroom, that is business class, you have to pay for that, same with the exit rows”. We chortled loudly. We ran into our crew after the flight on the light rail thingy in PHX, they were old school America West folks, we all talked about the old days when I was there. Thanks for the La Paz info, it was a delightful place, despite losing body fluids by the gallon due to sweat.

    1. Brett Avatar

      Yo – That’s awesome. But yeah, probably not a great time of year to go there. Still, I want to go back myself and spend some actual time there. Glad to hear my first impressions seem to hold up.

      1. Yo Avatar
        Yo

        Oh, the fun part, on the bus back from La Paz to SJD airport, a tire blew on the bus 25 miles out. Everyone was freaking about not making it to the airport in time, but, our driver, who was a very obese man, went out and changed it on the side of the road, with all of us in the bus with the AC on and got us back rolling in under 20 minutes, he was amazing!

        Also, I found another Mexican airline for you to try: Aéreo Servicio Guerrero. Tiny airline flying to 11 cities in Baja, Sinaloa and Sonora. They are the only scheduled carrier left in Guaymas. They fly Cessna Grand Caravans. We plan on going to Loreto if AA brings it back to more than once a week. Hell, we were seriously considering driving all the way down from Phoenix and seeing a few other cities in Baja, its an amazing place.

        1. Brett Avatar

          Yo – I decided to keep to only jet operators on my Jan adventure, but if I went with 9-seaters, then yeah, that one would fit along with Aerotucán in Oaxaca and of course, Aerus. Then there’s possibly the mythical AeroVega (https://theroamingjunketeer.com/2016/02/13/aerovega-and-the-white-knuckle-ride-to-puerto-escondido/).

          1. Yo Avatar
            Yo

            I sense a great new multi part story for your next trip south of the border!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.