Spirit’s November Data Is Here and It Ain’t Pretty


I was done for the year. Oh sure, I have the usual year-end posts, but I was ready to take a break. Then Spirit’s November data dropped, and I couldn’t just ignore that, could I? After all, who knows if it would even be worth talking about if we waited until the new year. So, let’s talk through it while you pretend to work today.

There are two really important things to know about November before we get into this. First, the government shutdown was bad news for airlines. Most airlines put out revised guidance that talked about the impact on a quarterly basis. But for Spirit in the throes of bankruptcy? We don’t really know.

And second, November was our first look at the new, slimmed-down Spirit. Remember this chart I posted last month?

Spirit Daily Scheduled ASMs

Data via Cirium

What this means is that November should have been our first look at whether Spirit was going to have a functioning airline buried in its bloated former self, but the shutdown has clouded that data somewhat. December will be our first real look.

Cash continued to leave the airline’s coffers quickly. Unrestricted cash dropped from just shy of $645 million to just over $586 million. That’s a lot of cash walking out the door in one month.

Unsurprisingly, November was bad on the income statement as well. It reported a loss of $72.7 million on revenues of just $239 million for a net margin of -30.4 percent.

This is better than the -35.6 percent margin in October, but that’s only without context. See, November saw available seat miles (ASMs) drop 19.5 percent. Unit revenues did climb from 9.13 cents to 10.00 cents. But if you cut 20 percent of your flights, and you can’t even boost unit revenue by more than 10 percent? That doesn’t seem like a good trade.

To be fair, there is still a lot more work to be done on the cost side. Things are starting to fall out quickly now with aircraft rent being cut in half by about $25 million, landing fees off more than 20 percent, and distribution down more than 18 percent. But wages are down slightly less than seven percent. More of that should come out over time as the incredible shrinking airline continues to… shrink.

The problem is that the math just doesn’t really work here. Revenues need to keep climbing significantly while costs must plunge.

Let’s pretend wages were cut in half next month which would save about $50 million. That’s ridiculously unrealistic, but then you still have an airline with a -10 percent margin. See what I mean? You still need a very healthy revenue increase of almost 10 percent to break even.

I am really interested in seeing what happens in December, but it’s still bound to be a money-loser. If good progress can’t be made soon, then things will get very hairy.

And now, enough of this. Merry Christmas to all who celebrate. Now go back to pretending you’re doing work.

Get Cranky in Your Inbox!

The airline industry moves fast. Sign up and get every Cranky post in your inbox for free.

Brett Avatar

6 responses to “Spirit’s November Data Is Here and It Ain’t Pretty”

  1. Matt D Avatar
    Matt D

    I just want to know who is still throwing (good) money at bad (Spirit) and why.

    Euthanize this mess already. They’ve already shriveled down by half in less than two years.

  2. Lost Luggage Avatar
    Lost Luggage

    Could it be Spirit is just running out the clock; looking for the holiday cash crush?
    January and February are dark periods for airlines.
    The creditors are in charge now.
    They are getting antsy and may decide to pull the plug! ?

  3. Tim Dunn Avatar
    Tim Dunn

    Airline chapter 11s always come down to someone not willing to take the 100% haircut they will take if an airline fails even on a short term basis compared to the partial haircut on a longer term basis.

    Dec will see an uptick – the government shutdown ended by Thanksgiving which was late in November – and all expectations are the December holiday travel (of all kinds) will be strong. Reduced industry capacity – including the healthy cuts from NK – are helping everyone else.

    Deal-making hits into high gear after the first of the year as does an increased focus on other weak airlines.

    Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to you too, Brett, and each of your staff and readers.

  4. DesertGhost Avatar
    DesertGhost

    I hope everyone enjoys the holidays they celebrate. I also hope that the holiday “Spirit” can continue for the entire year, not be practiced only at this time.

    Maybe the new year will open a new “Frontier” for low cost carriers in the US.

    Here’s to a great new year for all of us. Mazel tov!, Prost!, Cheers!, etc.

  5. George Romey Avatar
    George Romey

    I was at CHS last week waiting for a delayed AA flight to DCA. There was a Spirit flight boarding next to my gate but there could have not been more than 30 people at the gate. So, I sit in that area. Plane comes in, looked out the window it’s an A321. Meanwhile the Spirit Gate Agent announces that all Big Front Seats are empty as well as I think is coach with a middle blocked, selling and starting for $65. Didn’t seem like any takers. Eventually the 30 people board and afterwards the gate agent calls about 20 or so passengers that have not boarded. Plane pushes off and the missing passengers show up and start arguing loudly with the gate agent. Gate agent has to call over the intercom for assistance.

  6. Angry Bob Crandall Avatar
    Angry Bob Crandall

    I never want to see a carrier go out of business (OK, maybe Alitalia)! Hopefully they can turn things around.

Leave a Reply to Matt D Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Cranky Flier