|
Listen on Spotify Listen on Apple Podcasts
You want more on American? Brian Sumers and I go in-depth this week on the airline’s recent organization changes, the addition of premium seats, and finally bringing back in-seat video. Listen in now.
|
It’s definitely a choice for American to announce its summer 2027 plans two days after United, but it’s probably not one I would have made. United’s blockbuster adds, including 10 new cities, made a big splash. American’s 2027 plans are not going to do that, though that’s not all by choice. Despite the more modest plans, it’s what American is doing with its A321XLRs that still made this post-worthy.
American might have had bigger plans if its orderbook had behaved as expected. It originally thought it would have 13 new airplanes ready to press into service for summer 2027. In reality, it’s going to have only five thanks to delivery delays. That certainly puts a damper on this, and it means we’ll have to wait to see what the airline has up its sleeve for 2028. But we can at least get an idea today of how it is thinking directionally.
American has really tried hard to fluff this announcement by including already-announced service as well as frequency increases and seasonal extensions. That does give it some bulk, but I’m going to ignore all of that. First, however, let me list these out for you with the notable changed in bold:
- Charlotte – Barcelona 1x daily summer-only on a B777-200ER from May 27 (last flown in 2019)
- Charlotte – Paris/CDG 1x daily summer-only service starts March 4 instead of late March (already in schedules)
- Chicago/O’Hare – Tokyo/Narita 1x daily year-round on a B787-9 from March 19 (already in schedules)
- Miami – Milan/Malpensa 1x daily summer-only service starts March 4 instead of late March (already in schedules)
- New York/JFK – Amsterdam 1x daily year-round on an A321XLR from March 28
- New York/JFK – London/Heathrow adds a 4th daily flight year-round on a B787-9P starting March 28 (last flew in summer 2025)
- New York/JFK – Nice 1x daily summer-only on an A321XLR from May 6
- Philadelphia – Keflavik 1x daily summer-only on an A321neo from May 27
- Philadelphia – Porto 1x daily summer-only on an A321XLR from March 28 (intention previously announced)
- Philadelphia – Vienna 1x daily summer through the holidays on an A321XLR from May 6
On the surface, it looks like a big list, but if we eliminate everything that’s already in the schedule, routes that flew pre-pandemic, and Porto which was previously announced without detail, we’re really talking about 4 significant new routes. And three of those are the ones I want to talk about.
Vienna Stretches Those XLR Legs
AI-adjusted image via Gemini, and if you don’t know what this is from originally, click here
Ladies and gentlemen, we have a new clubhouse leader. At 4,333 miles, American’s Philly to Vienna flight is the longest scheduled A321XLR route in the world. Number two is on IndiGo which puts an XLR on Amsterdam to Mumbai starting in October. Believe it or not, that’s only 4,266 miles. Next is Iberia at 4,162 miles from Madrid to Santo Domingo. For comparison, United didn’t announce a single route over 4,000 miles this week with Dulles – Toulouse being the longest, clocking in at 3,957.
American has had its XLRs flying for a while now, so it has more experience with the airplane. If it can really do this 4,333 mile flight, that’s good news indeed for everyone who ordered this airplane.
Vienna has always been one of those confusing markets that you expect to have more service than it does. No US airline flies there today. The last time one tried was Delta from Atlanta way back in 2008, and that couldn’t have gone well. While Air Canada does fly from Toronto, nearly all service to North America has been handled by United and Air Canada-partner — and part of Lufthansa Group — Austrian.
Vienna just isn’t a big market. Looking at Cirium’s ARC/BSP data for the 12 months ending June 2026, Vienna from the US was smaller than Warsaw but slightly ahead of Geneva. With Austrian serving seven cities in North America, it doesn’t leave much room for others.
Of course, the A321XLR is the right airplane to try this route if you’re going to take a swing. There is some money to be found in that market, but I can’t image there’s all that much to be had outside of the Lufthansa Group/United/Air Canada joint venture. But I like the idea of trying an XLR on it. If it really does work all the way through the holidays — relying on traffic going to the Christmas markets — then it’s a really big win, but that does seem like more of a stretch.
The best use of the XLR is as a trial-and-error effort. Some will work, and some won’t. But this is one that’s worth trying.
Filling in the New York Gaps With the XLR
The other move of note is the start of JFK to both Amsterdam and Nice. This is how American is trying to thread the needle in New York. It is not competitive in any way across the Atlantic from there. How bad is it? Let’s look at this summer.
This July, American had a total of 10 daily flights across the Pond from JFK. Half of those went to partner hubs (3 to Heathrow, 1 to Madrid, and 1 to Barcelona). The others were Paris/CDG and Milan/Malpensa (year-round) along with Athens, Edinburgh, and Rome (summer-only). Edinburgh was the only A321XLR this summer. If we include joint venture partners and all NYC airports, then it rises to just over 30 daily flights to 11 destinations, but that’s a bit misleading because nearly half those flights go to Heathrow.
Delta, meanwhile, has 31 daily flights by itself to 26 destinations. Add in joint venture partners at all NYC airports and they’re up to more than 47 daily. And over at Newark, United runs nearly 42 daily flights to Europe on its own touching 35 destinations. Including partners and all NYC airports, it’s 54 daily flights.
The problem for American is figuring out how to expand its presence in light of this enormous deficiency. From a business perspective, it has Heathrow locked down, it’s the only US carrier flying to Tokyo/Haneda, and it covers São Paulo well. LAX is all set too. But then there’s the business traveler who needs to go to the next tier down. We’re talking cities like Amsterdam and Frankfurt, both competitor hubs that might make a difference to the person who wants to be AA-loyal.
There’s also the need to serve all those rich business travelers when they go on vacation to places like Nice in summer. American wants people to carry the AAdvantage credit card, so it needs to serve places where rich people want to burn their miles.
Trying to do that with a widebody as the number three or four in a market? It’s just going to bleed money badly. Trying to do that with an A321XLR? Well, it might still bleed money but a whole lot less of it. And if that helps bolster credit card revenues, then the math may work.
It certainly didn’t work for JetBlue which exited the JFK to Amsterdam market on its A321s in 2025 after only two years. And in the press release, American describes Amsterdam as a “time-tested vacation destination,” but I hope that’s not the plan for surviving winter on that route. This should be more about the business traveler.
In the end, there isn’t a lot to talk about for next summer at American thanks to those delivery delays. But you can get the sense of where the airline wants to deploy its fleet. I like Vienna, but I’m certainly more skeptical on the New York adds.
