For United, Luxury is In the Little Things


A translucent wall. A closet. A snack bar. A big TV. These aren’t things that we think of as being front and center when it comes to how people choose their airline, but when you add them up as United has done, they have the desired effect. With a little more time in between me and United’s recent media day, I’ve been able to think bigger picture about how United looks at things. And every often, that big picture… is small.

Sure, United did show off some big, new, shiny toys like its Elevated interior on the B787-9. But on the surface, anyone can outfit an airplane with flat beds. It’s the little things that make a big difference, and I found employee after employee very eager to show off those little things everywhere I turned.

An airline’s layout of passenger accommodations — LOPA for short — is like the blueprint for each aircraft. It’s the LOPA that shows where seats are as well as all the monuments that lie inside — galleys, lavs, etc. When it comes to a LOPA, there is only so much you can do. There is a finite amount of space on any given tube, but that doesn’t mean there is no wiggle room at all. And some airlines are better at maximizing their use of space than others.

Perhaps nothing has shown this off more in recent times than the United A321neo LOPA. On this airplane, United fit 20 First Class seats plus 57 Economy Plus and 123 regular Economy seats for a total of 200. Delta has 194 seats while American is at 196, so you would imagine that United’s configuration would be knee-crunching and disliked.

It’s not.

Filled with big screens full of content, wifi (faster Starlink wifi coming soon), and even a snack bar in the back, United says the A321neo has the airline’s highest customer satisfaction scores in the entire fleet. Perhaps this proves the point that while legroom matters, it’s the cumulative impact of every little thing that can make or break someone’s experience. And expertise with a LOPA can help enable those little things.

This LOPA-ninjaing was on full display at United’s media day on nearly all of its announcements.

For example, take the Relax Row which is a repurposed Air New Zealand Skycouch that will turn a set of three coach seats into a larger bed area on five rows of the airlines widebodies. This product does require adding an extra inch of legroom in those rows. That might be an issue except that in that back cabin where the seats will be, there is extra room available. I imagine the idea of wasted space gnawed at United, so it found something to do with it. This means United can take those five inches to put them to work generating revenue.

Or take the new Polaris flat beds on the transcon A321 Coastliner as well as the A321XLR. The 1-1 herringbone configuration seems to be the default way of fitting in beds on the narrowbody, but United knew that there had been concern about the claustrophobic coffin feeling onboard. It’s no wonder why:

The geometry of the airplane requires using a seat like this or forfeiting too much space, and it does look narrow here, doesn’t it?

But what did United do? It realized that if it lowered the walls a little, carved out more shoulder room, and then installed a translucent wall behind the traveler, it would create a much greater feeling of space and comfort with more light. No, it doesn’t make it so you face the window, which explains this look on my face, but it does still feel different than what others have done.

Then there’s the fancy Polaris Studio suite at the front of each cabin on the new B787-9 with the Elevated interior.

As I understand it, there is an issue with access to the crew rest area that makes it more challenging to put a big screen in those seats. But United figured it out. That new screen is a giant at 27 inches.

Contrast this with American which went with a smaller screen, because it was having trouble with certification. It just feels a whole lot different.

It’s not just up front either. When I walked to the back of the B787, one of the original project managers wanted to show off the 13 inch screens back there. This put United at the top of the class with airlines like Emirates and Japan Airlines. In the US, I don’t think anyone is above 12 inches. Is that a dealbreaker? No. But that extra inch is just part of the overall effort by United to keep improving the product throughout the airplane.

We can talk about the introduction of a closet and the elimination of overhead bins on the new CRJ450, or we can go back in time to the CRJ550 which did something similar. It’s not easy to be creative on a small, regional fleet. This is definitely creative.

To me, these small things were what United really had on display at media day. You can put the headlines in a press release, but when you step onboard and feel the difference, that’s where it will really shine. United seems to get that better than anyone these days.

Get Cranky in Your Inbox!

The airline industry moves fast. Sign up and get every Cranky post in your inbox for free.

Brett Avatar

12 responses to “For United, Luxury is In the Little Things”

  1. alfajores Avatar
    alfajores

    What United does well with its premium products on long haul wide body aircraft is featuring a unified product. While it took years for the first iteration of Polaris to roll out from the time it was first unveiled in December 2016, the product ultimately became consistent and standard across the 767, 777, and 787 fleets. Yes, some initial perks like wine flights and standard cool gel pillows came and went, but overall, a consistent seat is what UA achieved and that’s something DL is a long, long way from accomplishing (which is why it makes the ground experience in the Delta One lounge look and feel more premium, because apart from the A330-900 and the A350-900, the Delta One seat on 767s and A333/A332s is old, dated and not very comfortable). American has a more consistent product, prior to the roll out of the new Flagship cabin, but still has disparate seats on half of the 77Es and the non-P 789s and the 788s have different seats. The 77W a different seat too.

    While the look and feel of United’s Polaris 2.0 is stellar, whether the on board service matches it will be an open question. US carriers do not excel in customer service at any point in the journey. United’s food and presentation remains awful and cafeteria-level at best.

    1. Eric R Avatar
      Eric R

      UA’s product won’t be unified anymore as they roll out their new product.

      It’s easier to have a unified product when you haven’t updated the product for a couple decades.

  2. Mike (dontflymuch) Avatar
    Mike (dontflymuch)

    I have one gripe here with United, Brett, and youre included in it, and I realized it coming back from Seattle to DC with business class tickets only to be denied access to their lounge in Seattle because according to them only cross country business travelers to Newark had lounge access and not to IAD, after less than stellar international business class trips on united, but to destinations that dont get uniteds Midas touch…

    United has an amazing travel experience … but not for you… for influencers, and travel insiders (Brett) and 1k, sure. So they can go on social media and talk about how amazing United is, but for John Q. Travelers? Naww, you can read about others experiences.

    All in all you can say Im skeptical to incredulous when someone with access talks about how great United is serving them. Say what you want about Southwest or even (whispers) American, but Ive had more equitable experiences there where I feel like I’ve gotten the perks, not watched others get it when I still shell out the money.

    Sorry for the cranky response here

    1. Southside Emil Avatar
      Southside Emil

      What is the logic between the “haves” like Newark and the “have nots” like DC?

      1. SEAN Avatar
        SEAN

        DC maybe the seat of our national government, but NYC is where the real money & power is. That’s why EWR gets priority.

        1. Mike (dontflymuch) Avatar
          Mike (dontflymuch)

          There could be plenty of reasons, money in NYC being one of them, and while I know nothing about ewrs airport opps and I personally hate EWR, most of uniteds flights are housed in 50 year + temporary trailers in IAD and its governance cant be easy to deal with. Also United has a near monopoly on international flights out of DC except a few flights our of BWI and the rare DCA flight, so theres not incentive. And Im not saying every experience has been bad. I once got put in a new Polaris plane to Amsterdam when a volcano shut down my Icelandair flight, but idk often with United I feel like that meme where im the woman staring at the sad side of the mountain in the bus where everyone with a social media following or insider is the person smiling looking over the valley

      2. See_Bee Avatar
        See_Bee

        Corporate accounts in NYC, which are frequently financial institutions like banks and PE firms, tend to buy up in First and more last minute, meaning higher yield. UA is desperate to win/retain those pax

        IAD is a lot of government traffic, which buys more in advance and in coach, so lower yielding pax. Government pax loyalty is less sensitive as the government awards are allocated at the route level annually, so employees have to fly an airline on a certain route regardless

        1. Mike (dontflymuch) Avatar
          Mike (dontflymuch)

          All true. That or youre Kristi Noem, and you get your own private luxury jet

  3. SEAN Avatar
    SEAN

    Meanwhile, United is cutting 5% of flights do to the war in the ME & the surge of the price of jet fuel. Other airlines are choosing to increase baggage fees by up to $10.

    The brokered ceasefire was broken hours after being signed by both US & Israel, which should come as a shock to nobody as that is what they do.

  4. Eric R Avatar
    Eric R

    You should be happy that AA went for any type of screen.

  5. Mike (dontflymuch) Avatar
    Mike (dontflymuch)

    You see that’s the thing. When I sit in a crappy seat in American with no screen, I can at least think “Yep, this as good as it gets,” Yet I feel short changed when I’m sitting in a business class seat in United that hasn’t been updated since 2007, going cross country or international, reading about domestic lie flat economy seats! Or that great Polaris lounge some influencer is just gushing on United!! knowing that my business class seat (the most expensive one available on my route) wont get me access to. Makes me want to punch my 2007 Business Class seat…

  6. Mike Avatar
    Mike

    One other “little thing” United has done is to include the fancy Airbus Airspace ceiling lighting on their A321s. AA did not. Makes a huge difference in how the cabin looks and feels!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Cranky Flier