DOT Doubles Compensation for Bumping, Some People Won’t be Happy

I know this happened last week, but I haven’t had the chance to write about it until now. The DOT announced that it was going to increase the compensation for passengers who are involuntarily denied boarding. Is this a big deal? Well it could be. It certainly won’t make Robert Stack and the other volunteer bumpees happy, because they’ll probably have fewer chances.

First of all, let me explain exactly what’s happening here. In the fourth quarter of last year, out of 138 million passengers, there were about 125,000 that were denied boarding (pdf – page 33). Of those, nearly 114,000 were voluntarily denied boarding. In other words, the flight was oversold, the airline offered compensation in exchange for someone taking a later flight, and it was a done deal. People who take advantage of that won’t see more money in their pocket.

It’s the slightly more than 11,000 people who were involuntarily denied boarding who will get more. Those people wanted to be on that flight, but the airline couldn’t get enough volunteers. So, they had to deny boarding to someone who wanted to be on that flight. In the past, these people received the remaining value of their ticket to their next stopover with a cap of $200 if they arrived at their destination within 2 hours (4 hours internationally) of their original arrival time. If it’s later than that, passengers were entitled to double the value of what remains on their ticket to the next stopover with a cap of $400. Those caps will now become $400 and $800. Also, the number of seats on planes covered by this rule was reduced from 60 to 30. I had no idea it was 60 before. I’ve seen plenty of 50-seaters go out while still paying the usual compensation, so I’m not sure if this will make much of a difference practically.

So will this matter? If you love volunteering, it probably will reduce your chances. Airlines consider the expected cost of a denied boarding in their overbooking decisions. Now that the cost has gone up, the willingness to overbook will go down. So, those who love getting bumped won’t be happy. On the other hand, the .008% of people who have had the terrible frustration of being bumped involuntarily will be happy-ish to receive more money. I say happy-ish because they won’t actually get to their destination any faster.

Ultimately, this is just a way to discourage the airlines from overbooking. It may work, but it will end up reducing revenues for the airlines. You can expect to see more fare increases to help cover the costs.

Edited @ 1149a on Apr 23: Changed compensation to note that the dollar amounts are caps, but the compensation is based on the value of the ticket.

(Visited 51 times, 1 visits today)

Get Posts via Email When They Go Live or in a Weekly Digest

Leave a Reply

8 Comments on "DOT Doubles Compensation for Bumping, Some People Won’t be Happy"

newest oldest most voted
While I generally agree, there’s an admittedly small chance volunteers will see an increase in compensation. Since the cost of IDBing has gone up, the airlines have a greater incentive to (a) reduce overbookings or (b) get more volunteers when they do overbook. They’ll likely do some of both, whatever combination reduces costs most effectively. Where in the past an airline might max out VDB compensation at, for example, $400 in travel credits, they may now be willing to offer $600 (to avoid the $800 IDB cost). All of that said, I think ‘happy-ish’ for those involuntarily bumped is about… Read more »

Hey CF,

I miss those days of filling out the double digit denied boarding report at HP. It was really fun to get out to PHX to see the LAS flights in person with oversales of 30 or more. I’m getting all choked up just thinking about it.

My understanding of the new rule is that the new compensation for passengers who are involuntarily denied boarding is EQUAL TO THEIR ONE-WAY FARE UP TO $400 if arrival is within 2 hours of the original scheduled arrival, and EQUAL TO THEIR ONE-WAY FARE UP TO $800 for later arrival. My concern is that many, if not most, fares for flights within this country would be less than the maximum compensation, particularly if the airline can’t get the bumped passenger to his/her destination within two hours, so wouldn’t that give the airlines an incentive to bump the passengers with the… Read more »
Anon Coward

Overbooking will be reduced, IDB compensation will increase, and ticket prices will increase. This is a good thing: the system becomes more reliable for passengers — who by and large do not feel like playing a bit part in some revenue management accountant’s game of roulette!

Denied Dave

Does anyone know if there are regulations covering voluntary denied boarding compensation or is it ad hoc by carrier? I know with United and Delta, if the cost of a future flight is less than the value of the voucher the residual value can be used towards yet another flight. I just got off the phone with Frontier and they are holding firm that any residual value is dead. They are also claiming the voucher can’t cover 2 passengers on the same route/itinerary. Thanks!